9 Comments
User's avatar
Jordy Rosenberg's avatar

Charlie this is a brilliant periodization.

Charlie Markbreiter's avatar

Wow. Thank you, Jordy!!!!!

Siw Heede's avatar

Love all the threads that are pulled together here & I haven’t read Herculine but now I want to.

Your piece also made me think about how New York is the city of stars and Maria is a fallen star that lands in star city, a town that looks up to the stars. And here we live in a timeline where some deliberately wants to shoot down all the stars and that’s fucked up.

Thank you for this.

Ezra's avatar

this is beautiful, thank you

Charlie Markbreiter's avatar

Thank you so much for reading, Ezra <3

Kyle Ranson-Walsh's avatar

Haven't read Herculine (yet, apologies Grace!); it's compelling to compare the possibilities of what a NYC trans social scene can offer ten years after Maria takes off. That said, you are right, it's a "false choice between healthcare and housing, between a social life and financial stability."

Sam Rasnake's avatar

Great essay.

Charlie Markbreiter's avatar

Wow. Thank you so much for reading, Sam.